Hybrid Parallel Inference for Hierarchical Dirichlet ProcessesHybrid Parallel Inference for Hierarchical Dirichlet ProcessesOmoto, Tsukasa and Eguchi, Koji and Tora, Shotaro2014

Paper summaryopenreviewThis paper proposes two parallel inference algorithms for the Hierarchical Dirichlet Process (HDP) in a distributed/cluster setting. The proposed algorithms use a two-level approach to parallelization where the top level involves distributing the data to individual processors/machines across a symmetric multiprocessing (SMT) cluster and the second level utilizes existing algorithms earlier developed for parallel inference in HDP based models on each machine. The first algorithm uses the approximate distributed HDP (AD-HDP) algorithm of Newman et al (2009) whereas the second algorithm uses the Parallel HDP algorithm of Asuncion et al (2008). The proposed algorithms are compared against a full MPI implementation based on Parallel-HDP and are shown to scale better w.r.t. increasing the number of cores.
The paper is pretty much a simple extension of the existing algorithms for distributed HDP by simply reusing then on each machine and synchronizing. There is no discussion whether the existing algorithms (AD-HDP and Parallel HDP) could further benefits from the the SMT architecture, discussion about possible communication strategies among processors, or how certain issues such as merging of topics are dealt with (vis-a-vis the AD-HDP). Some discussion would be nice.

This paper proposes two parallel inference algorithms for the Hierarchical Dirichlet Process (HDP) in a distributed/cluster setting. The proposed algorithms use a two-level approach to parallelization where the top level involves distributing the data to individual processors/machines across a symmetric multiprocessing (SMT) cluster and the second level utilizes existing algorithms earlier developed for parallel inference in HDP based models on each machine. The first algorithm uses the approximate distributed HDP (AD-HDP) algorithm of Newman et al (2009) whereas the second algorithm uses the Parallel HDP algorithm of Asuncion et al (2008). The proposed algorithms are compared against a full MPI implementation based on Parallel-HDP and are shown to scale better w.r.t. increasing the number of cores.
The paper is pretty much a simple extension of the existing algorithms for distributed HDP by simply reusing then on each machine and synchronizing. There is no discussion whether the existing algorithms (AD-HDP and Parallel HDP) could further benefits from the the SMT architecture, discussion about possible communication strategies among processors, or how certain issues such as merging of topics are dealt with (vis-a-vis the AD-HDP). Some discussion would be nice.